Lake McCoy starts lower, at about $284,900; Sagewood starts at about $455,990. Ranges on record: Lake McCoy $285K–$600K, Sagewood $456K–$550K. Off-peak, downtown Orlando is about 29 minutes from Lake McCoy and 26 from Sagewood. The widest gap is to University of Central Florida: 48 minutes against 43.
Where Lake McCoy and Sagewood differ
- Price. Lake McCoy starts lower, at about $284,900; Sagewood starts at about $455,990. Ranges on record: Lake McCoy $285K–$600K, Sagewood $456K–$550K.
- Age. Sagewood is the newer of the two (built 2026–); Lake McCoy dates from 1976–2009.
- New homes. Sagewood is still selling new construction; Lake McCoy is not.
- Commute. Off-peak, downtown Orlando is about 29 minutes from Lake McCoy and 26 from Sagewood. The widest gap is to University of Central Florida: 48 minutes against 43.
- Distance. The two are about 1.4 miles apart in a straight line, in ZIP 32712 and ZIP 32703.
Side by side
| Fact | Lake McCoy | Sagewood |
|---|---|---|
| Price range | $284,900 to $600,000Both subdivisions; listings and recent sales, November 2026 | $455,990 to $549,99012 builder inventory homes, November 2026 |
| Built | 1976 to 1993 and 2005 to 2009Lake McCoy Oaks; Oak Hill Reserve | 2026, now selling |
| Builder | Not recorded | D.R. Horton |
| Home types | Single-family detached | Single-family, one and two story4 to 5 bedrooms; four floor plans |
| Typical size | About 1,300 to 4,400 sq ftSmaller in Lake McCoy Oaks, larger in Oak Hill Reserve | 1,828 to 2,807 sq ft |
| HOA | None, or about $73 to $84 a monthLake McCoy Oaks; Oak Hill Reserve (listing-reported) | Not verifiedFee and amenities not published |
| CDD | Not verified | Not verified |
| Gated | NoOak Hill Reserve: sources conflict | Not recorded |
| ZIP / jurisdiction | 32712Orange County, Apopka addresses; city limits not verified | 32703One listing site shows 32712. City limits status not verified |
| Drive to Downtown Orlando | 29 min | 26 min |
| Drive to Orlando International Airport (MCO) | 50 min | 48 min |
| Drive to Orlando Sanford Airport (SFB) | 40 min | 38 min |
| Drive to Walt Disney World (Magic Kingdom parking) | 48 min | 51 min |
| Drive to Lake Mary (I-4 at Lake Mary Blvd) | 27 min | 25 min |
| Drive to Downtown Winter Garden | 21 min | 23 min |
| Drive to Downtown Mount Dora | 27 min | 29 min |
| Drive to University of Central Florida | 48 min | 43 min |
| Drive to AdventHealth Apopka | 8 min | 10 min |
| Drive to Maitland Center (I-4 at Maitland Blvd) | 21 min | 16 min |
Every figure comes from the Lake McCoy guide and the Sagewood guide, where each one is dated and sourced. Drive times are off-peak routing estimates, not rush-hour times. Confirm school zones, fees and tax district for the specific address.
Questions about Lake McCoy and Sagewood
Is Lake McCoy or Sagewood more expensive?
Lake McCoy: $284,900 to $600,000 Both subdivisions; listings and recent sales, November 2026. Sagewood: $455,990 to $549,990 12 builder inventory homes, November 2026. Both ranges come from the listings and closed sales cited on each community's guide.
Which is newer, Lake McCoy or Sagewood?
Lake McCoy was built 1976–2009. Sagewood was built 2026–.
Do Lake McCoy and Sagewood have an HOA or a CDD?
Lake McCoy: HOA None, or about $73 to $84 a month Lake McCoy Oaks; Oak Hill Reserve (listing-reported); CDD Not verified. Sagewood: HOA Not verified Fee and amenities not published; CDD Not verified. Ask for the current fees in writing before you make an offer.
Which is closer to downtown Orlando, Lake McCoy or Sagewood?
Off-peak routing puts Lake McCoy about 29 minutes from downtown Orlando and Sagewood about 26 minutes. Rush-hour times are longer for both.
